Corning Beef and My First Reuban Sandwich

March 21, 2011

My first Reuban Sandwich was a long time coming.  You see, I am still a bit of a recovering vegetarian.  From the number of meaty posts of late, I can see that my recovery is going well.  There is so much good, humanely raised meat to be eaten, but still I sometimes hesitate and by no means eat it daily.  So I was reluctant to sign on to the meat making challenge of the year, Charcutepalooza.  Though, my curiosity and drive to learn about this art of which I know so little forced me to sign on.  My first challenge- brining.

Brining is so easy, it is hard for me to think of it as true charcuterie.  It involves soaking meat, or other foods, in a salty solution for a time and then eating directly, or cooking.  The brine infuses the meat with flavor and moisture, transforming an ordinary cut of meat into something special.  The Saint Patrick’s Day staple of Corned Beef is a perfect example.  An ordinary brisket is soaked in a spiced brine and a week later emerges as a completely different beast, begging for cabbage and potatoes or to be made into a Reuban Sandwich.

Saveur magazine featured a recipe in their last issue for Corned Beef.  I omitted the pink salt (sodium nitrate), because I did not have that on hand.  Because of that, the brisket did not have the signature pink color of the supermarket corned beef, but the flavor did not suffer.  This recipe is definitely a keeper.  My husband commented that he didn’t think that he could bring himself to eat supermarket corned beef again.  We agreed that the natural brown color of the meat was actually more appetizing than the artificial looking pink that we tend to associate with corned beef. We loved the meal, but what I was really looking forward to was the leftovers, made into homemade Reuban Sandwiches.

For weeks I have craved a Reuban Sandwich.  Perhaps this is a normal post-St. Paddy’s Day leftover item, but for me it is my first.  Why I regularly crave foods I have never eaten, I do not know.  I do know the sandwich was delicious, and I will make it again.  Early in the morning, I mixed up dark rye bread dough, using a recipe from Bernard Clayton’s The Complete Book of Breads.  The flavor was well developed, but the dough never rose properly despite adding extra hours onto the recommended rise time.  I intended to share that recipe as well, but I will spare you the disappointment.  Luckily, the bread was still very enjoyable so I used it anyway.  It worked fine, but the sandwiches were small.

Putting together a Reuban is easy.  Heat up the griddle, grease it, and toast one side of your bread.  Flip the bread and top one side with Russian dressing  and corned beef and one side with swiss cheese (or I used Irish cheddar).  Top the meat with a pile of sauerkraut.  Flip the cheesy side onto the meaty side.  Press down with a heavy pan until sandwich is heated through and adheres to itself.  Eat and enjoy!

And so a new tradition is born, I can see many years of homemade corned beef and Reuban sandwiches in our future.  Even the kids have signed on, minus the sauerkraut.

Corned Beef

adapted from Saveur Magazine

serves 10

1 Tablespoon whole allspice
1 Tablespoon cloves
1 Tablespoon coriander
1 Tablespoon crushed red chile flakes
1 Tablespoon mustard seeds
1 Tablespoon whole black peppercorns
3 bay leaves, crumbled
1 1/4 cups kosher salt, plus more to taste
3/4 cup sugar
1 Tablespoon pink salt (optional)
1 5-lb. first-cut beef brisket

Toast the spices in a skillet over medium heat until fragrant.  Heat 8 cups of water, sugar, and salt until sugar and salt dissolve.  Refrigerate until cool.  Combine with 3/4 of the spices (reserve the rest for cooking the brisket) and pour over beef in a large container.  Weigh meat down with a plate so that it remains submerged.  Cover and refrigerate for 5-7 days.

Drain and rinse meat.  Place meat in a large pot with reserved spices and cover with water.  Bring to a boil and then simmer for 1 – 2 hours or until meat is tender.  Remove from water and slice thinly.  Serve with potatoes and boiled cabbage, or make it up into a Reuban Sandwich!

Here is a printer friendly version of the recipe: Corned Beef

Check out this other recipe for brining:

Herb Rubbed Pork Loin with Onion, Raisin, Garlic Compote

Corning Beef and My First Reuban Sandwich on Punk Domestics

5 Responses to “Corning Beef and My First Reuban Sandwich”

  1. Hi,
    Being half Irish we always have corned beef for St. Patricks day. I love rueben sandwiches. My recipe is;
    sliced marble rye bread
    sliced corned beef
    swiss or guyere cheese
    Grey Poupon country style mustard
    sauteed onions in Olive oil, garlic, sugar, S&P, red wine vinegar and red wine or port is better.
    I will post the recipe on my blog.
    I really enjoy your blog…

  2. Francesca Says:

    I have often made salt-beef as we call it in the UK. I bought saltpetre (pink salt)on e-bay, believe it or not. It is meant to be illegal as you can use it to make bombs. I am very keen to make a Reubens Sandwich. What sauerkraut did you use and have you ever tried making your own?

    I also made Mango chutney a few weeks ago but a spicy one and it was really delicious.

    • Karen Says:


      I used a locally produced fresh sauerkraut, Alexander Valley Gourmet Sauerkraut. It is really good. I intended to make it myself, but didn’t get it started in time. That is funny about the sodium nitrate. I have run into similar issues buying lye for curing olives. Apparently that is used in meth production.

  3. In my opinionated opinion, the Reuben is the best hot sandwich in the world. (The best cold sandwich is summer garden tomato, salt and mayo on sourdough. The best hot-meets-cold is a BLTA. Can you tell I’ve thought this through?)

    This was a lovely post, and has left me drooling. Isn’t it nice being a former vegetarian? I have a grass fed brisket in the deep-freeze I need to pull out now and do this… Like, as soon as possible.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: